BAME Apprenticeship Awards All articles
Best Practice & Innovation

Following the Levy: Who Actually Benefits When Apprenticeship Money Changes Hands?

BAME Apprenticeship Awards
Following the Levy: Who Actually Benefits When Apprenticeship Money Changes Hands?

Photo: DFID - UK Department for International Development Graham Carlow, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A levy is not a strategy

Few instruments in English skills policy carry as much money and attract as little public interrogation as the apprenticeship levy. Employers with a pay bill above £3 million contribute 0.5 per cent of it, receive a 15 per cent government top-up, and draw the resulting balance down against approved training. The architecture is tidy. The outcomes are decidedly less so.

Since the levy came into force in 2017, several billion pounds have expired in employers' digital accounts without ever being spent, draining quietly back to the Exchequer. That single fact ought to reframe the national conversation. The question is no longer whether Britain is investing in apprenticeships. It is who that investment reaches, and whether anybody can produce credible evidence of it.

For those of us who spend the year reading award entries, the distinction is a familiar one. A submission that leads with a spend figure tells you almost nothing. A submission that leads with the names, levels, starting points and progression of the people that spending reached tells you everything.

The rebadging problem nobody wants to name

There is a practice in the system that everyone recognises and few will describe plainly. Businesses approaching their levy expiry date convert training they were already delivering into accredited apprenticeship programmes. A supervisor's existing induction becomes a Level 3 qualification. A familiar in-house course acquires a standard code and an end-point assessment.

On the balance sheet, the money has been used. In the community, almost nothing has changed. The individuals who benefit are, by definition, people already inside the organisation and already on a trajectory.

This matters disproportionately for BAME talent. The barrier facing Black, Asian and minority ethnic candidates is rarely a shortage of ambition or capability; it is a shortage of entry points and of the informal sponsorship that converts a qualification into a career. A rebadged programme redistributes a certificate to somebody who was already in the room. A genuine pathway recruits somebody who was not.

The distinction is not academic. It is the difference between an employer that has spent its levy and an employer that has used it.

Where the money is doing real work

None of this is to suggest the levy is a failure everywhere. A number of employers have treated it as a deliberate instrument for widening access, and their approaches repay close attention.

Transfers down the supply chain. Employers can pass up to a quarter of their funds to smaller organisations, and construction, logistics and facilities management firms have used transfers to fund starts at small businesses embedded in communities with large South Asian, African and Caribbean populations. The apprentice is recruited by the small firm; the funding comes from the large one. It is one of the few mechanisms in the system that moves money towards places the labour market usually overlooks.

Flexi-job and agency models. In health and social care, the creative industries and hospitality, employment is fragmented and project-based. Flexi-job apprenticeship agencies exist precisely so that a candidate can hold a stable apprenticeship across several short placements. These routes have opened doors for people who could not have accepted a single-site, five-year commitment.

Concentration at higher levels. The most acute BAME underrepresentation sits not at Level 2 but at Level 4 and above, and in degree apprenticeships in particular. Employers who have deliberately ring-fenced levy funds for higher technical routes, and who have rebuilt their recruitment pipelines to reach them, are producing outcomes that look nothing like the sector average.

The Growth and Skills Levy shift. The move towards a Growth and Skills Levy, with part of employers' funds now available for shorter, targeted courses and a protected share reserved for younger apprentices at lower levels, has created both an opening and a risk. The opening is greater flexibility for the employers who never had a coherent apprenticeship pipeline. The risk is that money drifts away from the very people the levy was meant to reach.

Level matters more than volume

A recurring blind spot in the levy debate is the assumption that more starts equal more fairness. National data complicates that. Apprentices from Asian backgrounds are well represented in some sectors and some levels, while apprentices from Black backgrounds remain notably underrepresented in higher and degree-level programmes, and in the sectors with the strongest wage trajectories.

Spending concentrated at the lowest levels, in the lowest-paying sectors, produces volume without mobility. Employers serious about the colour of their money should be able to state, without hesitation, how many of their higher-level starts went to candidates from BAME backgrounds in the last three years. Very few can.

What award judges should now demand

Recognition has always been a lever. If the BAME Apprenticeship Awards are to reward genuine practice rather than competent publicity, the evidence burden has to rise. Submissions in the Best Practice & Innovation category should be expected to demonstrate:

None of these indicators demands new bureaucracy. Every one of them can be answered from records a well-run employer already keeps.

The colour of money

The levy is a financial instrument, and financial instruments are neutral by design. Fairness has to be built into them deliberately, by people who decide where the funds land and who gets told about the opportunity.

That is why the most compelling award submissions of the coming cycle will not be the ones that spent the most. They will be the ones that can show, in detail and without flinching, exactly who their money reached, where those people started from, and where they are now. The levy is not a strategy. The strategy is what an employer chooses to do with it.


All articles

Related Articles

Beyond the Obvious: The BAME Apprentices Quietly Reshaping Britain's Most Overlooked Sectors

Beyond the Obvious: The BAME Apprentices Quietly Reshaping Britain's Most Overlooked Sectors

Unwritten Rules: The Emotional and Social Intelligence BAME Apprentices Must Develop to Survive Britain's Workplaces

Unwritten Rules: The Emotional and Social Intelligence BAME Apprentices Must Develop to Survive Britain's Workplaces

Racing to the Finish: How Compressed Timelines Are Quietly Robbing BAME Apprentices of the Learning They Deserve

Racing to the Finish: How Compressed Timelines Are Quietly Robbing BAME Apprentices of the Learning They Deserve